The Reality of Gender Dynamics in Modern Day China

Two high profile cases have thrust the issue into the spotlight. 
Monday 26 November 2018
It's not straightforward being a woman in modern day China. Photo: AFP

Images below may distress some readers.

Two high-profile controversies surrounding the mistreatment of women by famous Chinese men in the past week have ignited heated debate online, splitting public opinion and placing a spotlight on gender inequality in China.

On Tuesday, Jiang Jinfu, a model turned leading man in movies and TV dramas, admitted to committing domestic violence, and apologised to his Japanese girlfriend Haruka Nakaura and her family for hurting them with his “impulsive behaviour.”

jian-jinfu-CNN - gender
Chinese heartthrob Jiang Jinfu recently admitted to assaulting his girlfriend. Photo: CNN

“Whatever the reason, I should never have raised my hand,” the 27-year-old actor wrote to his more than 17 million followers on Weibo, the Chinese equivalent of Twitter. “I’m ashamed of my action and won’t defend it in any way. I stand to bear the consequences for my behaviour and accept the punishment.”

The confession and repentance from Jiang, who was studying in Japan before the story broke, came after Nakaura posted pictures of her badly bruised face and body on Instagram, which quickly went viral in China after being reposted on numerous Chinese social media platforms. Adding to the list of injuries, there are also claims that he kicked her until she miscarried.

haruka nakaura - gender
Haruka Nakaura’s bruised face. Photo: Haruka Nakaura/Instagram

Her original caption read: “I’ve recently made those who care about me worried – but I’m alive. Jiang Jinfu’s disappearance is indeed related to me but I can’t say more at the request of my lawyer and the investigators.” Nakaura’s Instagram account is now private.

Divided opinion
Jiang’s unusual public statement has attracted more than 210,000 comments that show surprisingly divided public opinion. Though a sizable number of people condemn his actions, with many calling for a boycott of his movies, many others praise his apparent “courage” in owning up. A vocal and not insignificant number go further still, blaming the victim, and criticizing her for “provoking” Jiang, without any proof. But isn’t this besides the point?

Also on Tuesday, one of China’s best-known tycoons, Yu Minhong, issued a profuse apology for his “extremely wrong” and “inappropriate” remarks about women at a business forum in Shanghai last weekend.

In videos posted across the Chinese cyberspace, Yu, founder and president of New Oriental, the country’s biggest private educational services company, was seen telling a full-house audience that “degeneration of Chinese women has led to degeneration of the nation.”

“Men without a conscience but with a lot money – that’s the criterion Chinese women today use to choose their men,” explained the 56-year-old self-made billionaire, who is known for being an inspirational speaker. “That’s why we say the state of a nation depends on its women.” Later in the speech, after recounting a profanity-laced anecdote, Yu reiterated his point that “women have destroyed China.”

Denunciations came almost immediately on the internet, prompting Yu’s first attempt to clear the “misunderstanding” that his remarks had caused. “What I really meant was that the level of women represents the level of a nation,” he wrote Sunday on his Weibo page, which has almost 15 million followers.

“High-quality women mean high-quality mothers, who are able to produce high-quality children. Men’s values are guided by those of women: If women pursue an intellectual lifestyle, men will become wiser,” he added. More backlash ensued with critics accusing Yu of repeating the same message in a revised form.

One person who wasn’t taking it lying down? Chinese actress Zhang Yuqi, who blasted him in a retort on Weibo, saying “I can only say that Peking University’s education and New Oriental’s success doesn’t help you understand the value of women and doesn’t let you understand what equal gender relations is. This doesn’t even help you understand what equality is.”

zhang-yuqi-weibo - gender
Zhang Yuqi’s Weibo post.

As the share price for his New York Stock Exchange-listed company plummeted, Yu released an open letter. “(My remarks) reflected my problematic views on genders and lack of respect for women,” he wrote. “I have learned my lesson, and will study more about gender equality and actively create such a corporate culture at New Oriental.”

Women face systemic discrimination
Mirroring reactions to the Jiang scandal, the Yu story has also divided the public online. While many are up in arms in calling out Yu’s misogyny as well as the hypocrisy between his speech and his reputation as a leading educator, others have come to his defense – insisting that “political correctness” shouldn’t deprive him of the right to tell the “truth.”

Despite the famous slogan of “women hold up half the sky” by Communist China’s founder Mao Zedong, experts and activists have long argued that women continue to face systemic discrimination in the country due to both political and cultural factors.

While surveys suggest that sexual assault and harassment are prevalent in China, the number of actual prosecutions remains small – and the #MeToo global movement has had a difficult time gaining much traction in Chinese society.

“The awareness of Chinese women that they have to fight for their rights didn’t exist,” Hung Huang, an author and media personality who has become a prominent feminist voice in China, told CNN in a recent interview.

“A lawyer friend of mine who specialises in helping women has to go to western China to educate police … that they have to protect women (who report domestic violence),” she said. “Most policemen’s responses were, ‘Really? But who doesn’t beat their wife?'”

“We’re at the beginning of exploring culturally that how to redefine Chinese women and Chinese women’s role in society,” she added. “Is there a political solution to a cultural problem?”

Source: Steven Jiang/CNN International, South China Morning Post

Read: China Says Dolce & Gabbana’s Social Media Posts Are Racist – Do You?