Was Vincent Van Gogh Murdered? New Film Says He Was

The mysterious circumstances around Vincent Van Gogh’s death have found their way onto the big screen in 'At Eternity’s Gate'.
Friday 7 September 2018
Will we ever know the truth behind Van Gogh's death? Photo: CBS/YouTube

It is generally accepted that Vincent Van Gogh passed away as a result of a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the chest.

But what if that wasn’t exactly what happened?

At Eternity’s Gate stars Willem Dafoe as tortured artistic genius Vincent Van Gogh.

In it, the painter is shot after a struggle with local youths near the village of Auvers-sur-Oise outside Paris, where the artist spent his final months in 1890.

He died 36 hours later after staggering back to the local inn in the dark.

While most historians agree that Van Gogh killed himself, renowned painter and Oscar-nominated director Julian Schnabel fuels the theory that he was killed by accident.

Great debate has always surrounded the artist’s death, though the long-accepted conclusion is that that he committed suicide.

Legendary French screenwriter Jean-Claude Carriere – who co-wrote the script with Schnabel – passionately opposes the notion of suicide, saying “There is absolutely no proof he killed himself. Do I believe that Van Gogh killed himself? Absolutely not!”

“He came back to the auberge with a bullet in his stomach and nobody ever found the gun or his painting materials,” Carriere added.

“What we have been fighting against is the dark romantic legend of Van Gogh. In the last period of his life Van Gogh was working constantly. Every day he made a new work,” he said.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Martín Saráchaga Subastas (@martinsarachaga) on

His final weeks, when he painted the ‘Portrait of Dr Gachet’ – which set a world record when it sold for $82.5 million in 1990 – were “not at all sad”, the writer argued.

Schnabel insisted that a man who had painted 75 canvasses in his 80 days at Auvers-sur-Oise was unlikely to be suicidal.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Steven Naifeh (@stevennaifeh) on

The theory that Van Gogh did not commit suicide was first raised in a 2011 biography of the painter by Steven Naifeh and Gregory White Smith.

Schnabel said neither the gun nor “the painting material he had that day were ever found. It is strange to bury your shit if you are committing suicide.”

Though many specialists in the art world refuse to even acknowledge the murder theory, preferring to remain with the suicide theory.

At Eternity’s Gate is also likely to open a new front in the row over Van Gogh’s ‘lost’ sketchbook, which purportedly resurfaced after 126 years in 2016 and was authenticated by two eminent art historians last year.

Veteran British expert Ronald Pickvance claimed the book was “the most revolutionary discovery in the history of Van Gogh” studies.

But the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam hotly disputes its provenance and dismissed the drawings as fakes.

The book, originally a ledger from the Cafe de la Gare in Arles where Van Gogh stayed at various times between 1888 and 1890, features prominently in the film.

Schnabel and his team examined the drawings for themselves with the director pressing Dafoe’s hand down into them, he said, to “force a transmission – a connection between me and Van Gogh.”

It clearly worked, with Defoe, who looks uncannily like the Van Gogh the film, already tipped for the best actor prize at Venice.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Igor (@clivodini) on

The actor said in shooting the film in the fields around Arles where the artist painted and in the asylum at Saint-Remy where he was held, “we flirted with Van Gogh’s ghost”.

Schnabel said the film was not meant to be a factual biopic, because “all history is a lie”.

“I don’t care if the notebook is real or not real, if he killed himself or didn’t kill himself. It’s irrelevant. But in the film it is nice to know there is another set of possibilities…”

The film was also a chance for “me to say things about painting… and it was a lot of fun to speak through Van Gogh.”

The ebullient New Yorker also wanted to correct the “bad rap” that Van Gogh’s friend Paul Gauguin gets from history.

Van Gogh may have cut off his ear when the painter announced he was leaving him to return to Paris, but “Gauguin really cared about him,” Schnabel said.

“He is portrayed usually as an arsehole. Anthony Quinn (in the 1956 film Lust for Life) played him like that, but he wasn’t.”

Source: AFP/Relaxnews

Related: To You They’re Blobs of Colour, To Art, They Sparked a New Movement